Goody2Treats

We were met at with door with a big smile. The owners were very insightful regarding desserts and have another bakery in Castleton. They had a Red velvet chicken and waffle cupcake 🧁sounds delicious 😋

From the moment I walked in, the staff greeted me with such warmth and genuine friendliness—it felt like visiting family. The display case was full of beautifully decorated cupcakes that looked almost too good to eat… almost! I tried a few different flavors, and every single one was incredible—moist, flavorful, and topped with the perfect amount of frosting. The red velvet and peach cobbler cupcakes were out of this world! What really stood out was how attentive and helpful the team was. They took time to answer questions, make recommendations, and even packaged everything carefully so it would travel well. You can tell they truly care about their customers and take pride in what they do. If you’re in Indianapolis and have a sweet tooth, Goody 2 Treats Bakery is a must-visit! Delicious t

Very unique and different flavors of cupcakes. The chicken and waffle cupcake and the biscoff cupcakes were 10/10. My wife loved the strawberry banana pudding also. Prices are really good also. Will definitely return. Staff was very patient, kind, and took the time to explain all the different offerings.

The staff are very nice and describe everything you ask. The service is quick. The cupcakes taste fresh and are moist. Definitely will be back.

The staff was very friendly and helpful. She named each item and the prices. Unfortunately I was not satisfied with the taste. Everything tasted old except for the cobbler which needed to bake longer. The bakery is beautiful and I wish her the best, but I won’t return.