Greystone Castle

Nice little dive bar. Half is a bar and half is sit down eating. I absolutely loved all the taxidermy decor! There was no wait time to sit, service was quick and friendly, and wait time for food was not very long. My husband and I both got a prime rib sandwich which was absolutely delicious but huge! If you aren't starving or normally don't eat a lot, split one with someone. The onion rings are gigantic and yummy and cheese curds were good too. Very much recommend!

Local gem. This a sportsmanship bar. Animal and fish mounts everywhere. Casual beyond casual. But one of the best Prime Rjb Sandwhiches you will find in town. Everything on the menu including some wild game options. Good drink prices.

This place was slammed when we went Saturday night. The girls that were working, worked their tails off. I have to assume they were short staffed because it took forever to be seated and served. That said, they were very friendly, sat as soon as a spot became available, and took our order right away. It took a long time to get our food but we enjoyed some college football and cocktails and checked out the taxidermy. I had a burger that was well worth the wait, and the couple next to us had a prime rib sandwich that looked out of this world. It’s a cool place, we would probably try to go on a slower day next time

I recently visited Greystone Castle at 8 N Madison Ave, in Sturgeon Bay, WI. Wow, what a great experience. When I think of a bar in Wisconsin this has to be it..it's full of animal mounts and plenty of Packer memorabilia..I happen to show up for a Packer game and was treated like a local..I enjoyed the shot every time the Packers scored..I ended up going there a couple of times. A must go.

We keep finding little "hole-in-the-wall" gems on our travels and this one is high on my list of "Gonna Go Back Again." Don't let your initial impression of the "Castle" scare you away. The building is nothing to look at, but that's not what counts. Inside the walls are a menagerie of wild game and antlers. Our server was Hanna, she was fast, courteous and checked on us a couple times during our meal. They claim to have the best prime rib sandwich in the world. I totally agree! We had the Prime Rib sandwich, I guess I should say we split the prime rib sandwich because it was a slab of prime rib about an inch and a half thick and cooked just right. Along with it we had the in-house breaded mushrooms which were also BIG! (see picture). We are going to go back and take a few of our fri