Henry's Homemade Ice Cream

Let me start off by saying the ice cream was good. It tasted just like homemade ice cream should. That being said it wasn’t worth the price. It was over 13$ for two single scoops in waffle cones……. That’s kind of where our visit went down hill. Don’t get me wrong. I don’t mind spending money for quality things. But that’s a bit much for two scoops of ice cream. I mean, that’s two tubs of bluebell. Which a half gallon of theirs is $18 so how does two scoops for $13 makes sense. Also, the presentation in the cooler was less than appealing. The ice cream was very runny very fast. Which I do expect from homemade so that’s not a huge deal but everything seemed very dated in this place and not in the good ways. I mean, I’ve paid $18 for a milkshake and felt like it was worth it. This was not t

I went with my mom yesterday for the first time. Service was so friendly and they were generous and encouraging with the samples. I ended up getting a sundae with spumoni ice cream (that had pistachios and cherries mixed in!) and my mom got pecan praline in a chocolate dipped cone. It was so good and we will definitely be back to the more flavors. The ice cream is made in-house and definitely tasted fresh. They had the classic flavors plus a bunch of interesting combos I’d like to try next time.

The best ice cream I have ever had in my life time. ML Toffee on a crunchy chocolate dipped cone. Jane was outstanding with her service!

Yes, yes, and yes please. If you are any where near this places try it. The standard flavors are creamy and delicious and the unique flavors are fun.

Henry’s offers old standbys and creative new flavors of ice cream. The name says homemade and it tastes homemade. I can taste the milk fat. We visited on a cold January day to buy an ice cream cake. The cake was nicely decorated. Some reviews have said the service was not good. That was not our experience. Staff were welcoming and friendly.