Hometown Pizza - Middletown

It's written all over your face. You don't have to say a word. me and my cousin went in to do a carryout order as soon as you went in you seen it on their face. I had a combination pizza that I wanted. my cousin had pepperoni and cheese on a pizza she wanted. we paid separate separate orders. long story short I had to take the pizza I ordered back because it was all pepperoni. they was nice. gave me my money back. offered to make another pizza but the time you wait. it is what it is. the pizza was good and the manager was nice. if I have to say what was on their face then this message isn't for you

Had a great lunch outside on the patio! Great pizza and friendly staff as always. Update 1/7/23 Hometown Pizza offers a welcoming atmosphere and a friendly staff. Their thin crust pizza is crisp and flavorful and the original or thick crust is great as well. Do not forget to order the cheese sticks with garlic butter dipping sauce they are a great way to start the meal

Gave us the wrong order. Ordered a simple pepperoni pizza, gave us some random pizza. Wouldn’t answer any calls or messages to be able to fix this. I can’t eat mushroom so unfortunately this will not be eaten because it’s the COMPLETE wrong order and now we must unfortunately throw this out.

Ordered a pizza and small breadsticks. When I received them, they were horribly put together. The toppings weee clustered on only 2 pieces of pizza instead of the whole thing, the breadsticks were crammed together and both were misshapen. They can’t even blame the delivery driver, because the boxes weren’t crushed and were clean on the inside meaning that they weren’t thrown around by the delivery guy. They were placed in the boxes already looking like trash.

My first time eating here and OMG!! The pasta, the sauce and the garlic bread is amazing! Which is why it’s already half eaten 😂 will for sure be coming back on my lunch breaks! I’ll even be brave enough to try the pizza! (Picky eater 🫣) staff was amazing too. Super friendly and helpful.