I Love NY Pizza

Overall pretty good. Will be back. The slices were good. The cheese was processed but a decent quality. I've certainly had worse. The lasagna had TONS of cheese. Unfortunately we pigged out on appetizers so I ended up taking it to go. The Garlic Parmesan wings were GREAT! We moved here for months ago and they were the best I've had so far. My wife enjoyed her Spaghetti & Meatballs. I asked her for a rating and she gave it a "six or seven." We ordered a large deluxe pie to take home. It looks great! The only things we did not like was the 4% fee for paying with a card. Really put a bad taste in my wife’s mouth when it came to tipping… especially since there isn’t any wait staff.

This pizza was amazing!!! I am from New York and that was real authentic New York pizza. I just recently moved in the area and I can definitely say I will return. Me and my husband loved the food. It was hot and fresh! Definitely recommend if you want authentic New York style pizza!

The pizza, subs, pasta and especially the service are amazing. I’ve honestly never experienced a restaurant that goes so far above and beyond like this place does. One night I placed a DoorDash order and the restaurant realized they had made a mistake. Not only did they immediately reach out to me, but they personally delivered the corrected order themselves. I was completely blown away. It may seem like a small thing, but it meant everything that night. I had a house full of girls waiting for pizza and it was getting late. Since discovering this place a year or so ago, I’ve ordered from them many times and have always been impressed by both the food and the customer service. They definitely have me as a loyal customer and I recommend them to anyone who will listen. Thank you for consist

The food was pretty good, it did taste like NY. There was a decent amount of space and tables, I could picture a little league team of some sort coming in after a game in there. I am torn on giving the 4 for service. The only knock I had was, because it was our first time we didn't see the details on the menu (A LOT to choose from), but we ordered a special, chose our toppings and when we go to pay, the price was significantly higher (as if we ordered something else) and I had to ask what happened...the plus is the cashier was trying to help us bring the cost down by switching the special we picked because one of the toppings was a specialty item and would've cost way more if we were charged straight up, the downside is if I hadn't asked, the change nor the price difference would've been

⭐️⭐️⭐️ – “Good Crust, But Overall Just Okay” We ordered from I Love New York Pizza while staying at a hotel in Locust Grove. The order was delivered through DoorDash, so the prompt delivery (and the fact that the food arrived only warm) is more about the delivery service than the restaurant itself. The pizza had a nice New York–style thin crust, which I enjoyed, but the flavor was mild and a bit greasy overall. The jalapeño poppers unfortunately didn’t impress—the cheese inside wasn’t fully melted, and the sauce provided was overly oily and unappealing in appearance. If you’re after a decent thin-crust pizza, this place has potential. With a little more flavor and attention to preparation, it could really shine.