IL Gusto Pizzeria & Italian

Nobody puts Baby in the corner.. This hidden gem is tucked away off the main road and you would not know if it was there, but once you go, you will never forget. Authentic Italian Pizza in Sussex County, NJ. The classic plain slice is as good as it gets. Perfect harmony of sauce, cheese and crust. Definitely one of the best I have had in 2025. Enzo is a master of Pizza. I tried his grandman pizza, hits on all levels. Nice thin square that had the perfect crunch. Apparently they have only been open for 6 months at thjs point. Was not expecting this amazing pizza experience. They will definitely be top of the charts on the Pizza Hunters App for sure. Cant wait to go back.

I visited this pizzeria during my trip and it was such a pleasant surprise. The pizza was absolutely delicious, I ate a “Sicilian style “with a soft inside and a perfectly crispy crust on the outside, just the way I like it. The ingredients tasted fresh and high quality, and you could really tell that care goes into every pizza they make. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming.They were incredibly kind and making sure we felt comfortable. They even gave us great recommendations from the menu. If you’re in the area, I highly recommend stopping by. It’s definitely a place I would love to visit again!

Absolutely loved this place! The staff was so friendly and welcoming, the pizza was delicious. The sauce had amazing flavor, and everything tasted so fresh. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to!

If you're looking for a takeaway pizza that will impress, this pizzeria is definitely worth checking out! The pizza I tried was absolutely delicious: authentic flavors, fresh ingredients, and a perfect crust—crispy yet soft. A true treat for the taste buds. Plus, the staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, creating a welcoming and professional atmosphere. I can’t wait to return and try more of their menu. Highly recommended!

**Best Pizza in Sussex County!** We've been coming here since they first opened, and from that very first order, we were treated like family. The owner always greets you with a big smile and a great sense of humor, and his wife, who runs the register, is incredibly sweet and welcoming. The food is consistently delicious and made with the highest quality ingredients — all at very reasonable prices. They’re also happy to customize orders to your liking, which we really appreciate since our family is picky. We love a light crust, and he never disappoints! This place is a true gem, and we highly recommend giving it a try. You won’t be disappointed!