Isabellas Italian — Fayetteville

The service and food were great! We had dinner here on Valentine’s Day. It was busy but we still had great service and the food was really good. I really enjoyed the burrata and beggars purses with shrimp and the crème brûlée!

Food came out fresh and was overall good. The prices are ridiculous and especially because the waitress never mentioned it was extra for salads. She said “do you want a soup or a salad” as if it came with the entrees. It was overpriced and there are better options taste-wise at other places. Overall, I probably won’t be back.

Outstanding meal with excellent customer service! Melissa took care of our every need! Beef tenderloin Oscar, oysters on the half shell, scallops, calamari, French onion soup and olive oil cake for dessert! Overall an amazing meal! Highly recommend!

This was my wife and I's third trip to Isabella's, and our 2nd Valentine's Day dinner there. Our first two experiences were amazing, however, this trip was less than satisfactory. Our reservation was for 8pm, and we were seated just a couple of minutes after. We did enjoy a drink at the bar while we waited (1 can of Michelob Ultra and 1 Cosmo=$24.00). The waiter arrived quickly and appeared knowledgable about the menu and the Valentine's Day specials. We each ordered coffee, salads, shrimp carbonara, Oscar Style Fillet, and an appetizer (Fritters and Shrimp). It took more than 15 minutes for our coffee and water to arrive. And the waiter brought the wrong appetizer at 8:45. I tried to get his attention, but he left in a hurry. I flagged down another server and advised them we received the

I recently dined at Isabella’s Italian with a party of six, and overall the experience was disappointing. While some of the food was good, there were notable issues. The mahi mahi was overcooked, and the portion of asparagus served on the side consisted of only four small pieces, which felt extremely minimal given the price point. Overall, the food was decent but inconsistent for what we paid. The service was the most frustrating part of the evening. Our waitress was inattentive and unfriendly throughout the meal. Our water glasses sat empty multiple times, and it was difficult to get her attention when we needed something. Interactions felt rushed and abrupt. The wait time for our food was excessive. We waited close to an hour for our meals despite the restaurant not being crowded at t