Islamorada Fish Company

This place was amazing! Our server was very experienced and it was very evident that she loved her job. My niece and I stopped in for late lunch. The Server was very patient helping us with making a decision on food selection. Ultimately we both ordered the Mahi Mahi tacos and Gator Bites. I debated on giving 4 stars for food but unfortunately my fish was a bit dry and chewy and taco shell was not warm, but very tasty!! The ultimate surprise was when we inquired about Military discount we were advised that we were both entitled to $25 off our meal since it was Veterans Day and we were both Veterans. We were pretty stoked. Getting the discount reinforced my respect for this business. Will definitely be returning!!

Amazing grouper and crab with literally the freshest salad I’ve had nearly ever! Broccoli was perfect! Elk sliders we so ridiculously good! First time and absolutely will return. Jessica thank you for your hospitality and kindness as well as recommendations. Fast service and everyone was kind from the sweet hostess Jordan to Jessica! Great team and great food and great service! We will be back!

I love this restaurant I wish all bass Pro Shops had one. I have ate here for years. The Staff is always great. the Bar is awesome. The beer is spot on cold. The Alligator bites are awesome the shrimp is wonderful. I love the Bread and Salads. Alligator tacos are great as well. I have also had the Brisket Burger. I can't wait to come back. I always say I have to go to Bass Pro to get my bait but it is really to eat. I have a ton of Bass Pro and Cabela's videos on my YouTube Channel (thevirginiastew)

We went for dinner on a Sunday and we're seated immediately. It was pleasantly quiet and our food was served in about twenty minutes. We started with the alligator bites and it was crisp and delicious. I got the fish and chips which was very good and enough for my Son and I to share. My wife got the mussels with wine and garlic they were perfect and fresh. Our server was very nice and attentive. The only drawback was the beautiful big aquarium was down which had been a centerpiece there. We definitely will be back when we would like some good seafood.

Love this place. The portions are a good size, we've now had the pleasure of having Parker as our waiter twice and he's phenomenal. He's super attentive, has good recommendations, constantly checks to make sure we're good and have everything we need. My husband had the ribeye and shrimp this time and the steak was absolutely massive and cooked perfectly. I've had the fish and chips and they never disappoint. The elk sliders are always juicy and delicious. We always have to order two orders of alligator bites because my 5 year old who typically doesn't care for any type of meat will demolish an order with the spicy ranch instantaneously. Always a calm and relaxing atmosphere.