Italian Gator Pizza

ALWAYS a consistent, PERFECT NYC slice that is NEVER NEVER NEVER shloppy. (iykyk) I ALWAYS come here when I have to head over to Gville. I have been begging them to come to Jacksonville Beach for YEARS, please help me bug them. The ONLY good NYC pizza in the whole entire area. Great job as always, guys!

Came for the first time in years recently just for a little trip down memory lane. The pizza was excellent but I got charged over $11 for 2 pepperoni slices when they're listed as $3.59 online? Part of the reason I came was to save some money so I was little surprised to see that. Not sure if the pricing needs to be updated or a mistake was made, but now I'm extremely hesitant to go again.

I liked the idea of buying a slice rather than a whole pizza.

joey was fab. pizza was so yummy. garlic knots even better.

I'm from NYC and would say their slices (reheated) are among the best I've had. Most eat them while hot though or reheat when you get home. Counter service only and no seating.