Jahnke's Creamery

Fantastic ice cream!! Nice flavor selection, a bit of something for everyone and the actual ice cream is delicious! I particularly love the quality and flavor of the waffle cones! They even have fantastic hot food! Easy spot to pull in off the road with plenty of parking and a lot of nice seating, outdoor games, etc.

5 star experience. When Jahnke’s was called Pops they had the best ice cream concoction of all time called the Turtle Sundae. This item was not on the Jahnke’s menu however the friendly employee Cheyenne (spelling?) made me a Turtle Sundae. I would highly recommend adding the Turtle Sundae as a mainstay menu item. Other than that this place is a must visit.

Just take my money (salted caramel ice cream )was absolutely awesome. The homemade waffle cone the best. Great little ice cream place on NY-28. If you're up near Cooperstown, stop in and enjoy!!!

We came here for food and ice cream. Our kids loved the playground! And my husband and I love that the meat and ice cream are local. Great flavors. We met the owner and his kids on the playground and they were all very kind. Looking forward to coming back all summer!

I used to love coming here when it was previously Pop’s and am happy to report that Jahnke’s lives up to Pop’s. Very good ice cream, great flavor selection. Coconut crunch was so good. I wish they would add Turtle sundae to the menu- then it would be perfect! 😊