Jake's Ice Cream Siesta Key / Bay Rd

This is the best ice cream my husband and I have ever had. Both of us are professional pastry chefs too so I think that says something. The staff were friendly and it has a great location. I love supporting local businesses and this is a must stop. I will definitely be back if I’m in the area. The cookie dough ice cream had lots of cookie dough and the key lime biscoff crust ice cream was just perfection. I ate every single last drop of that ice cream. Thank you so much!

This is the best home made ice cream I’ve had in a long time! The owner greeted us and walked us through each flavor explaining the quality of the ingredients inside. He started handing us samples to ensure we selected the right one…best day ever! It is so refreshing to hear a local business owner speak to customers with such passion for the product. We will definitely be making the 2.5 hour drive back and recommending it to all of our friends! True gem! We enjoyed the espresso, turtle beach, and strawberry!

Some of the best ice cream that I've ever had. My family agreed. A must stop anytime I'm in the area. I had the cookies and cream with a scoop of biscott. Look forward to trying new flavors next visit!

The best icecream I've tasted in a long time. Especially the Biscoff. Jake is a very friendly and welcoming guy. Loves what he does and it shows. Makes all his icecream with wholesome ingredients and it shows. Don't leave Sarasota without trying this icecream!

Fun ice cream selections and the folks working here are so friendly and fun too. I appreciate the metal tasting spoons rather than the disposable ones (nice touch). Their ice cream scoops are super generous and yummy! The photo is of a small cup and 2 “small scoops”.