Joe's Brooklyn Pizza Webster

Should have read the reviews. We ordered online and pizza arrives via Door Dash right on time - and cold. We call the restaurant and their response? “Just reheat it in the oven.” A pizza that takes 15 minutes to deliver should be, y’know… hot? At least Door Dash refunded the delivery fee. Really wanted to enjoy a first-time experience, not a last one.

Wish we had read reviews prior to ordering. We were on the road driving home from a 2 hour road trip and decided to place an order for pick up upon making it back into Webster. We placed an almost $90 order. Received both email and text verification that our order was received. Received a status update that our order was ready via the link sent to us. Got to the restaurant and it was closed. Door locked, lights off. Tried calling number and there was no answer and message stating that the number does not allow messages. My husband tried calling another location for info, they were not sure and encouraged him to call DoorDash as they manage their orders. Door dash then told my husband that the hours on line stated they were open, and would have to call the restaurant to verify they were ind

Similar to other customer experiences, I ordered online on a Tuesday, received an order confirmation with estimated timeline for order completion, and then I also received a notification that my order was ready. Unfortunately, when I arrived to the store they were closed. It seems they didn’t update their hours and online ordering was still available even though they were closed. I called another location and was advised to call DoorDash for a refund as their online ordering goes though that service. DoorDash was then able to refund my money after they tried calling the store and no one answered. It’s unfortunate that this seems to be a frequent issue with this location.

Very good pizza. But, WAY too expensive. It cost $33 for an XL pepperoni pizza and they don't give enough pepperoni (see pic half the pizza covered decently, but the other half skimped). If you don't mind spending around $10 more for pizza and then feeling like you should get more for that money, try this place. Otherwise, give Pizza Stop a shot - same quality, but around $10 cheaper. Note to owners - consider adding more toppings so the whole pizza is covered (see right side vs. left side in pic). At least then, if people are spending the extra money here, there would be no complaints about the pizza. Again, no knocks on taste just on price/toppings.

Had my 1st pie at Joe's. Absolutely fantastic. I'll b there every time I order. I had the white garlic, and looking forward to try more of their menu. Great job 👍