Joe’s New York Pizzeria

The best pizza and wings in upstate NY. I am not a big pizza guy, unless it’s garlic, but I love this pizza and the wings are an experience on their own. If you want properly cooked wings that will bring you pure satisfaction then deff try the bourbon molasses extra crispy. I’d share a photo but they got chowed before a picture could be taken.

I heard good things before and was traveling through so i decided to stop. Glad I did, the slices looked good but nothing spoke to me so I got a small meatball sub. After crushing the first half I decided I needed to take a pic and leave a review. It was that good. I imagine anything with the red sauce will be choice because it's delicious. Service was great and the food came out really fast.

The pizza is great! However the Stromboli is the best! Joe and his family are great people and have been a staple in the community for a long time. Anyone driving through West Winfield and hasn't tried Joe's should stop and check it out, you'll be glad you did!

Ordered a veggie calzone. Had i known it was 28.00 for just veggies...not realizing there was an upcharge i would never ordered it. (yes i was told over the phone the cost however i thought it was a mistake as the menu online had 17.00 listed) anyway it was undercooked. Will not go there again.

I only have been here a few times. I will have to update the review when i order a whole pizza. Today i went in to pick up 2 slices for my gf. I was surprised at how busy they were. It took a little while for the chicken wing slices but that was a given with the volume of orders and pickups that they had. I am not a fan of chicken wing pizza. Im very picky about how it has to be done. I had a little bit of one of her slices and it wasnt bad. Def get a side of ranch tho for dipping or extra wing sauce. Normally i dont like a lot of places chicken wing pizza's so thats a plus in my book. I will update the review the more i order from there and actually order something for myself