Johnny's New York Style Pizza

New Review and new Pictures! 08/05/2025 Thank you so much to Johnnys, I am very appreciative to how much you love your establishment. My family and I are here again…It was absolutely amazing. Fresh and hot off the presses. I want to say thank you to the owner. I can’t wait to come back in and now be a lifelong customer. The pizzas and Calzone were top notch. I will add the calzone pics but here is the pizzas. Delicious!! Update! 05/10/25 I have been meaning to make this update since a couple days after my original. I am highly impressed with the email I received from the Johnnys Owner about the pictures I posted. I don’t do the reviews for any other reason than for different establishments to make their amazing food even better…A touch above the best! I like to think of myself as a Calzon

I wanted some authentic pizza so I Googled and was surprised to find Johnny’s not far from my home. Walked in to a sit down family friendly comfortable experience. You guys know how I feel about customer service and they hit it out of the park and I only had carry out. I can’t wait to dine in!! And the 🍕 OMGggg, sorry I don’t have pics guys but it was amazing. Cheese, sauce and Pepperoni to the edges! And even tasted great heated up the next day. Sooo Fayetteville Johnny’s New York Style Pizza ty for restoring my faith in getting great service and great food without having to go all the way back home to Bmore!

Came to Johnny's for a quick slice right before closing and was met with a smile from Amanda as she greeted me and took my order. Paul was in the process of preparing to close and heard my order and immediately began to prepare it. At the end of a long day the customer service still shined thru which is why I will always return to Johnnys where the food is hot and the beer is cold!.

I was a consistent customer through door dash, I ordered from this restaurant at least 2 to 3 times a week. When I first started ordering from the restaurant I was trying something new every time I placed a order on DoorDash and couldn’t find any thing that was close to good, there pasta is very bland and lacks flavor, the one slice pizzas are premade and when I ordered the one slice of pizza with extra sauce, I received a plan cheese pizza with tomato sauce added on the top of the pizza warmed up🙄, I was at my wits end but I decided to give the restaurant one more try and I tried their 10 piece wings which I surprisingly like but the price for them is outrageous and they don’t even come with a side or drink but I continued to order them because it’s hard to find a place that cooks wings c

We celebrated Halloween in our traditional way and ordered pizza yesterday.. This is not our first time ordering from Johnny’s Pizza , but it will be our last. A few things happened with our order. I ordered a 10 piece Mike’s honey hot wings, which were only covered in honey. I called the store to inform them my sauce was incorrect. Abigail informed me the honey hot was a premixed sauces. I politely informed her that this could not be honey hot as my wings only had honey on them. She was nice over the phone and gave me two options to make it right. So my husband when to get another 10 wings but a different sauce (hot wings). When I tell you there was barely any sauce on the new order of wings. Terrible!!! Now let’s get to the pizza. Their pizzas in the past were flavorful. We had a Hawaii