Johnny's New York Style Pizza

This is our go to spot for pizza every Friday night! About 8 months ago we decided to try as many pizza restaurants to find the best quality for the best price. After trying many other restaurants we decided Johnnys Pizza was the best option. Why? The food quality is great, the price is fair and the service is consistently excellent! Megan behind the bar always does a great job making sure everything is right and that we’re well taken care of! I highly recommend this place!

Food was great! I've been to several other pizza places in the area, and this was by far my favorite. The drink glasses were large so little need for constant refilling and pricing was very fair. I went on Sunday and there was only one server and one busser working, but they were still able to seat and serve each guest quickly and professionally. I got the baked penne with sausage added. Food was hot, well prepared, and portioned. I will be visiting again!

The pizza was overly greasy, and all of the cheese and toppings kept falling off the pizza. I took the pizza back to the store, and one the employees just told me “That is how New York Style pizza is, and entire staff thinks it’s normal.”. I’m from the Northeast, and I have NEVER seen a New York pizza like this. Originally I asked for a new pizza, but based on the rude comments from the worker, I only asked for a refund, and took my business to Dominoes. I was a customer of Johnny’s Pizza for the past decade, but I will no longer buy pizza from them.

I have been a fan of Johnny’s Pizza for over 10 years, particularly the Sugarloaf spot. The pizza, salad, wings, and the craft beer from all over. I stop going during the pandemic era and went back recently and everything was still on point. They even upgraded the patio to a backyard-like oasis. Now the only thing that has changed is the influx of New England Style (hazy) beers on the wall. I guess when in Rome do as Romans. But not a fan; I missed the days of triple IPAs. Nonetheless, I still recommend for Pizza, wings, and a Greek salad.

My family frequently visits Johnny's. Every visit the staff is friendly and give amazing service. I've taken friends and family from out of town here and they give the pizza 10/10. Thanks so much for the team at this location for providing a great place to grab a beer and enjoy some pizza.