Johnny's New York Style Pizza

We had a great time, our first time trying! The atmosphere was fun, Sunday night football playing, and the food was great! They had $.75 wings and we got the hot Hawaiian pizza which was delicious. We’ll be back!

Spending an evening with family in Peachtree City, pizza was the choice and out of convenience tried Johnny's in PTC. I had low expectations because thin, crispy NY/NJ style pizza in Newnan and PTC are bad. We used to live in Smyrna/Vinings, and the Johnny's there was very doughy like Papa John's. I was pleasantly surprised the thin crust was thin, crispy and not floppy. We had a Margarita and a build your own and both were excellent. Nice little vibe inside as well, albeit we did take out. Highly recommend Johnny's in PTC.

I used to come here almost every week because the pizza is honestly great. The flavor, the crust, and the quality always kept me coming back. It was one of my favorite spots when I was craving a good slice. Unfortunately, the service has really turned me away. On my last two visits, my party and I walked in, sat down, and waited quite a while without ever being greeted or acknowledged by the staff. What made it even more frustrating was watching multiple tables that came in after us get greeted and helped right away. After the second time it happened, we ended up leaving without ordering. It’s disappointing because the pizza is genuinely good, but being ignored twice made us feel unwelcome. Because of those experiences, we’ve decided we won’t be returning.

Pizza okay, cheese not quite right, no stretch just breaks. Wish we would have had special recommended to us, would have received a large pizza instead of medium for $0.40 more. Was a 40 minute drive, would go again if in area but would not go out of the way just to go.

Tried this location recently and overall it was a really good experience. The atmosphere was fun and welcoming. Our food came out hot and fresh, the pizza had great flavor, and the service was friendly even though they were a little busy. It’s not perfect every time based on other visits in the past, but this time everything really hit the mark. Good food, good vibe, and we’ll be back.