Johnny's New York Style Pizza

I ordered a cheese pizza expecting a simple New York–style slice, and what I received was extremely disappointing. The pizza had an overwhelming amount of low-quality cheese, barely any sauce, and a thick, doughy crust that didn’t resemble New York style at all. The balance of ingredients was completely off, making it unpleasant to eat. What made the experience worse was the customer service. When I contacted the restaurant about the issue, instead of simply addressing the concern, I was asked to take photos as if I needed to prove that the pizza was poorly made. That felt unnecessary and dismissive for a pretty straightforward complaint. A quality pizza shop should stand behind their product and customer experience. Unfortunately, this visit fell far short of that.

After a long day of travel, I wanted some Chicken Parm. I ordered from this restaurant because it was the closest to where I was staying. My food was delivered. The food was boxed with care. All that I ordered was included. I’m disappointed with the CP. It was EXTREMELY dry. The marinara was practically nonexistent. The chicken and spaghetti was so dry. I did not enjoy this meal. I ate some of the salad I ordered - even the salad had so much lettuce in it. I wish I could ask for a refund. It was not worth the price I paid.

Came into this establishment after being a longtime customer of the Johnny’s pizza on Virginia Avenue I ordered a Mediterranean salad. The presentation was not good it did not look as advertised no pinwheels, and the Cam olives were extremely salty. The lettuce tastes pretty good so the cucumbers, tomatoes, taste like tomatoes, and the onions were extremely thin, but overall the salad was like a five so it was OK but the calzone and the sauce was not good I got charged for the sauce. When I asked her to correct it, she said oh ma’am I can’t correct. Any of that all I can do is take 20% two dollars. The service was great. The waitress was wonderful but the way the manager handled the situation with the calzone being not appetizing and she refused to take it off. I was totally disappointed

We had an amazing server, Tiffany, who recommended us the calzone, and it was incredible. The big size was enough to feed 2 people and leave leftovers and it was cheaper than the pizza! She was very enthusiastic and made our meal 10 times better.

Great pizza 🍕 large the toppings were great customer service fast polite staff I ordered on line really easy 😀 👍