John's Drive-In

I stopped by for ice cream two days in a row, and it was worth it! A fun little spot in Montauk with friendly staff who recommended the Oreo Mint, which was spot on. They offer several creative homemade flavors, and each one is tempting. Easily my go-to place for ice cream in Montauk.

Amazing icecream but the ordering system is a little unorganized. People would come in from two doors and would mess up the line of first come first serve. They should close the middle door and tell people to come in from the left. On the other hand the icecream was very good.

No frills burger spot in Montauk - quite possibly the most budget friendly eatery as well. Everything was pretty good. The burger was tasty and pretty decently sized. Fries were tasty but a little over done, The Fish and Chips were good, and the Buffalo Chicken Wrap was flavorful. Jalapeño Poppers were cheddar cheese - so know before you order. The Mozzarella Sticks were not bad either. Solid meal. Only quam was the bathroom - only one and the lock apparently isn't the greatest. Anyway, I'd visit again. If you're not a fan of kids or dislike loud... this is not your place, or at least not your place to eat in. It's loud, really loud. That being said, it is recommended.

Banana Oreo and toasted coconut ice cream were absolutely delicious! They also had warm toasted cashews which were amazing. Prices were very fair considering the quality and the friendly services. We will definitely come back!

Me and my coworkers came in eyeing this place for weeks on our way to a job site not far away. Had high hopes. The cashier called my Puerto Rican coworker “amigo” right off the bat and it threw us off as awkward, especially since she clearly wasn’t Hispanic or Latino….she took our whole order and THEN informed us it was cash only. So we had to leave. She never mentioned the online ordering option or that there’s an atm inside. We came back today (a week later) with cash, and the we had the same cashier who sort lacked energy or happiness? Didn’t seem happy to be there, no energy, wasn’t rude but wasn’t polite. But we ordered food and were not disappointed at all. The burgers were relatively cheap, absolutely delicious and filling, and we saw John the owner there and he was so polite, and