Keller's American Grill

We not only had a great time, we came back the next day! Food was great and service even better. They made us feel at home. Next time we are in the area we will be back.

2/13/26 9pm. Service and food is terrible. The hotess that seated us looked us up and down and seemed to have a uppity attitude as maybe disapproving us or something. Waitress Aleah never asked if we needed a refill, napkins, steak sauce, no nothing! After we signed the check another girl came by to ask do we need a refill. 1st visit and definitely our last ! Just because we are known on TV doesnt mean we want to waste our money and time!

This place had ALOT of issues- will not return! French onion soup had minimal flavor, shrimp cocktail was good (4 shrimp for $15, despite menu saying $14), side salad was underwhelming (would have chosen another side had we known it was so basic & small), ribs were good (yay), sirloin was chewy (but edible), both loaded baked potatoes were dried out (didn't taste fresh despite having a reservation when they opened), and filet mignon was tough & chewy. I LOVE steak and simply couldnt eat it. I ended up sending it back. After reading reviews (while there), I saw I wasn't the only one with issues (sort on most recent) I had regrets that I'd booked this place. Overall, meat wasn't good quality and/or cooked properly. I actually question if it was frozen and unthawed improperly. No manager cam

Casey at the bar is amazing! She makes the evening fun. The coconut shrimp are amazing and the fried portabello mushrooms make the two-hour trip worth it. I wish my salmon was fresher. It was very smelly and tasted off. We will definitely be back.

Chose Keller's for a quiet anniversary dinner. My wife and I were the first two seated by an unfriendly hostess, at booth right off the main aisle with plenty of two-seat booth available. Two more customers were seated at a table for four beind us, four more were seated right next to us within reach!?!?! Ordered Honey glazed Salmon off the menu, received lemon dill salmon.