Kelly's Inn

First time at Kelly’s and WOW! I had no clue I could get decent crabs out of season so close by, amazing! We called the night before and reserved 2 dozen and a table in the dining room. Great server, old-timey dive vibes, crabs were delicious, and you can get bar drinks! We’ll be back :)

When we first walked in it felt like we walked back in time to the 70s. Being children in the 70s this was great!! We loved the atmosphere! The service was top notch. Hailey took great care of us! The crab was delicious. We will be back. If I have to pin point anything I would change would be the seasoning on the crabs were too heavy for me so I will ask for light seasoning next time. And one more thing my husband's food took a very long time to get to the table. We were in no hurry but it was a long time after I received my crabs. They were busy though and we will definitely be back.

First timer. Got the backfin crab cakes... on point. Stuffed mushrooms...on point. I'm a Baltimore native and this is the first time I can say I enjoyed the crab in PA. Cole slaw how I like it. Fries better quality light batter I 🤔 yummy. Ate in the bar as the dining area opened later. I'm an Ex smoker with a vape on the ready just incase. It was too smokey in the bar but I'll plan better and eat in the dining room which is non-smoking in the future. Service was a bit slow.I felt like I had to ask for my Guinness expected it quicker. The server was young and scrambling so...it happens, otherwise she was on point :) Definitely going back

My bestie took me out for my birthday here! It is definitely a hidden gem in York, and the food was good. The soup was delicious and the potato salad was out of this world. My hubby wasn't too impressed with their soft crabs and my son loved his pasta dish. The fried pickles are a must! I think the crab cake was a little bland but it had a lot of crab meat in it. We got there an hour before they closed and the waitress was rushing us through the service.

It was ok. Not the kellys inn that I remember, not even close. Haven't eaten here in 15 yrs... or more. Just kinda out of the way for us. But I did eat here a lot back in the day. Sat bar side. Great bar atmosphere. Smoking allowed but wasn't terribly smokey for us non smokers. Food was meh. I'd maybe get a basket meal, some fries and a drink but go elsewhere for a dinner. Definitely don't get the steak. Drinks were good and the broasted chicken was the best of everything we ordered. Prices are good and in this case you get what you pay for unfortunately. But place was busy so good for them. ***Oh!!!! The menus online are not accurate. No scallops etc and so on, that why we went there in the first place for the seafood.