Keystone Pizza

Used to go to Keystone all the time growing up, and loved the pizza the atmosphere! Had the night out with the family and stopped in to grab some food! Something about all that has changed, the employees were or seemed distracted. They were eager to help once they got to the counter. The dining area seemed dirty and dim. Salad bar was out of salad and looked neglected. When the employee came to drop off the pizza I made a comment of how the pizza looked very good, to complement them and was dismissed in silence. Pizza presentation was nice and pizza tasted good. Could have used more cheese and sauce. Pizza had a piece of plastic from a cheese bag it seemed. I left with a 5/10 experience and felt that it has deteriated substantially from what it used to be. These places should be thr

This place has great pizza. The recipes and choices have remained pretty much the same for about 50 years! It's a nice, family-oriented place with an arcade room for kids - a nice feature for parents - and a great lunch menu. The decor may seem a bit outdated, but I like the the nostalgic feel of the place. It's no wonder this place has been successful for so long... keep up the good work! 👍

Came in for the first time to get some food before looking at the Christmas lights at Indian creek. The service was quick and friendly. The food reminded me a lot of Idaho pizza but less acidic, I honestly preferred it over Idaho pizza. The cheesy bread stick were great! We also ordered a combo pizza and a pepperoni pizza and both were good. My niece won a stuffed animal from the claw machine and loved the experience.

Just wanted to send a heartfelt thank you to the kind person who turned in our son’s wallet at Keystone Pizza. Everything was still inside—cash and cards included. A huge thank you as well to the Keystone employees who went above and beyond by contacting the Caldwell Library to track us down. We are so grateful for your kindness and honesty!

I ate here a few days ago. It has a very dated interior. I would bet the interior has not been updated since the 1970's. The arcade has very old video games; games that I have not seen in a very long time. That being said I had the lunch buffet, so the pizza and the salad bar. I like the salad bar, it had many options to select from. The pizza was good and fresh, but nothing spectacular. They also served bread sticks alongside and with the pizza. Three different types of pizza were served. I don't know if they mix up the kinds of pizza they serve but they were good. It was decent pizza, but there are a lot of places that serve decent pizza out there ..