Koi Omakase

Brooklyn55 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY · Sushi restaurant

Rating
4.4/5
★★★★☆ 4.4
Reviews
20
Rank in Brooklyn55 5th Ave, Brooklyn
#1
of 1 restaurants
City Percentile
0%
rating percentile
Address
Koi Omakase, Brooklyn55 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone
(917) 728-7563
Status
Closed · Opens 1 PM

Koi Omakase is a restaurant located in Brooklyn55 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY. It is one of 1 restaurants listed in Brooklyn55 5th Ave, Brooklyn. Its 4.4-star rating matches the Brooklyn55 5th Ave, Brooklyn city average of 4.4 stars. Based on combined rating and review volume, it currently ranks first among restaurants in Brooklyn55 5th Ave, Brooklyn. There are 10 photos associated with this location.

About Koi Omakase

$49 – 14 Courses (No Drinks) 75 mins of pure art $69 – 15 Courses + Unlimited Drinks 75 mins of pure indulgence 📍 55 Fifth Ave, Brooklyn, NY 👇🏻 Reserve on Resy

Hours

Saturday1 PM–3 PM, 5 PM–10 PM

Customer Reviews

★★★★★ 5.0 Jimmy Liang · Dec 2025

We selected the 14 course omakase—it was the perfect amount for us to enjoy each without feeling like it was a heavy meal. Each was so unique and tasted amazing! You can really taste each and every ingredient. While there was a small wait at first, we were so grateful that the front of house was able to accommodate us with an earlier time since we arrived before our reservation. The restaurant was very clean, modern in its decor, and the chefs worked seamlessly with each other. Aside from the parking and traffic around that area (but it’s expected), this dining experience exceeded our expectations! Will be saving this spot for another visit soon!

★★★★★ 5.0 Zev Levit-Ramos · Dec 2025

Let me tell you, KIMYO Omakase (formerly Koi Omakase) has quietly become our absolute go-to omakase spot in the city. We’ve been 5–6 times now and it’s consistently fantastic. The fish is always incredibly fresh, the rice is seasoned just right, and every piece feels like its own little treat rather than filler between highlight bites. Course after course, it’s just clean flavors, great texture, and really thoughtful toppings. The vibe matches the food. The space is dark, chic, and comfortable, so it feels special without being stiff or pretentious. The staff is genuinely friendly, the sushi chefs are kind and engaging, and the whole experience always ends up being fun rather than formal or awkward. On top of all that, the value is unreal for the quality you’re getting. it feels like you

★★★★☆ 4.0 Amy DoubleOSeven · Nov 2025

I came here with my friend and we ordered the $49 omakase. The service was quick and efficient and the pieces were very good. I do have to say that I have tasted more flavorful pieces but for the price I am supriced of the quality and tasty pieces. I highly recommend this place and I know you would be satisfied. I also felt a bit rushed but the sushi chef took that into consideration and I also understand there is a window especially if there is a big party coming in next so I know that is nothing to fault.

★★★★★ 5.0 xiao sien · Jul 2025

From start to finish, Koi Omakase delivered an unforgettable dining experience. The quality of the fish was exceptional—each piece was incredibly fresh, expertly prepared, and thoughtfully presented. You can truly taste the difference in every bite. The ambiance was elegant yet relaxed, with a minimalist design that allowed the food to shine. It’s the perfect setting for both a special occasion or a quiet evening out. The service was equally impressive—attentive without being intrusive, and the chef took time to explain each course, adding a personal and educational touch to the experience. Highly recommend for anyone seeking top-tier sushi and a refined omakase journey.

★★★☆☆ 3.0 Becky Zhang · Jul 2025

Tried Koi Omakase for their BOGO deal 13 courses plus miso soup for $69 for two people, running from 6/1 to 9/1. The portions were on the smaller side but I still left feeling full and satisfied. It's not your usual omakase experience though like it felt a bit rushed with how quickly the pieces came out, one after another. The sushi bar is U-shaped and can seat about 25 people. The standout piece was definitely the king salmon with foie gras like so rich and buttery. The miso soup was okay though I wish it was served a little hotter. The staff was really nice and attentive, and you can tell they're working hard to keep things moving during this promo. Fish quality was decent and a few bites had rice that didn't hold up too well, but nothing too major. For $69 total, it's hard to beat thi

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance

Services

Sushi restaurant

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.