La Sicilia

I ordered takeout of Firecracker Calamari as well as a pizza pie on New Year’s Day totaling $36, and it was DISGUSTING! This version of calamari is advertised as fried calamari mixed with fried hot peppers. Instead, I received fried calamari, drenched with vinegar and mixed vegetables. By the time I got home, my food was soggy, and the calamari was not tender, very rubbery and overcooked. Whoever the chef is for this restaurant clearly is not authentically Italian. I spoke to a manager about the situation and all he recommended was a credit of eight dollars towards my next purchase in store. The calamari was priced at $18. He refused to give me a refund. I find it diabolical for him to think that I will want to eat there again after the horrible experience. I will take that loss, but at l

Went here last weekend because we were in the area and we were blown away with the food and service. We ordered calamari and pasta dishes. Everything was so fresh and tasted AMAZING! Even the bread was fresh and hot. This is the real deal Italian food with a real deal chef. We can't wait to come back to this gem. Overall 5 stars for everything.

I ordered a meat lovers pizza and this is what a received. No meat on the pizza it was burnt and no flavor. I also ordered Eggplant Rollatini all sauce and no flavor. Very disappointed.

It was ~40+ years ago that I was last at LA Sicilia when I lived on Washington Avenue with my 1st Wife. The food was excellent, the Waitstaff was courteous & cheerful, and the Prices were reasonable. Almost half a Century later... the Staff is all new, but nothing g about this place has changed a bit! My Vegetarian Wife loved the Fried Zucchini Appetizer & her Stuffed Manicotti with Marinara Gravy. I loved the Long Hots Appetizer & Sliced Sausage with Peppers & Onions Hot Sub! Our Waitresses, Marbella & Jamie were cute, sweet & very attentive to our Table... and were rewarded appropriately. Worth a stop after a beautiful stroll though the Cherry Blossoms in Branch Brook Park or taking care of business in North Jersey.

Wonderful restaurant. Absolutely excellent service, always warm delicious bread to start, charming interior. I love the pasta and marinara sauce, any chicken dishes, and they have stuffed artichoke which is very rare and hard to find. :)