Lewis Brothers Ice Cream

We visited on a Monday afternoon in mid-June 2025 for a after lunch snack. There was a line when we arrived but they seem to move through pretty fast. It is at a busy intersection so watch out for kids who might be hanging out outside as there really isn't much seating inside the establishment. We ordered: - Milkshake peppermint stick - Milkshake coffee heath - Milkshake cookie monster - Milkshake black raspberry We decided on milkshakes because we were on the move and it was easy to walk with the cups versus cones. The ice cream was good but nothing special. We did fine it annoying they gave us tiny straws so a lot of the chunks in our shakes we couldn't suck up the straw and had to open the lid to eat them after we finished the rest of the drink. If you know it's not going to fit up

I know it is just serving ice cream but when you feel seen it is just a great feeling. Beverly, the manager, makes me feel seen every time I come in. Customer service at its best. Plus they have sorbets and one vegan option (flavor change every week).

I was on an ice cream mission throughout my two days staying in P-Town And at this point I had already tried three other places, this was my last place to try. Service was very impersonal, no smile, no personal interaction... Just meh! But I was there for ice cream, so I went ahead and bought two scoops on a waffle cone, Mudslide Chip and Mint chip. It was good, nothing spectacular. The mint chip did not taste minty enough for my taste. Fair priced.

Perfect after dinner stop, open late and has all the options, delicious self serve and even a boozy White Russian flavored ice cream.

The ice cream is definitely homemade and it’s tastes delicious! I had the small cup of Hot Fudge Sundae with almonds. The workers are friendly and provide great service. And the prices are reasonable. When you visit Provincetown, I highly recommend getting ice cream at their place!