Lombardi's On the Bay

First off let me start by saying how extremely friendly and helpful the staff were. They where extremely friendly and welcoming. As for the food itself, I got the crabcake and the clams and these were amazing and extremely fresh. Their scenic location on the waterfront proximity to the fire Island ferry make sure a wonderful date night.

I highly recommend this restaurant. All of its dishes are very tasty. The penne alla vodka is excellent and the chicken marsala is exquisite. The bar offers a wide variety of cocktails. In the summer, they have outdoor service where you can enjoy the sunset. For this reason, it is one of my favorite restaurants

Everything we ordered was delicious. It was a quiet night. My cup was always full, and the staff very friendly and attentive. I would come again. The menu is very expansive.

Booking our wedding at Lombardi’s on the Bay has been such a wonderful experience, and so much of that is thanks to Jeannie. From the moment we first met with her, she made us feel completely comfortable and genuinely excited about planning our wedding. My fiancé and I are juggling a lot right now — planning a wedding while raising our baby — and Jeannie has made the entire process feel easy and stress-free. She took the time to answer all of our questions, explain every detail, and never once made us feel rushed or overwhelmed. What really stood out was how personal she made the experience. She truly cares about the couples she works with and made us feel like our wedding day mattered just as much to her as it does to us. Her organization, communication, and warmth made such a differenc

Lombardi's on the Bay truly shines when it comes to service. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel like VIPs. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and made excellent recommendations—he was always just the right amount of attentive, checking in without being intrusive. James, the manager, took the time to personally introduce himself and ensure everything was to our liking. He even shared a few behind-the-scenes insights about the menu. His hands-on approach and genuine care for the guests made the experience feel extra special. It’s rare to find service that so effortlessly blends professionalism with warmth!