Long Island New York Pizza

My family and I just tried this place for the first time. We were all very happy with the pizzas and garlic knots. This pizza is very good, although not to the level of our favorite pizza place, Bleecker Street Pizza in NYC.

Long Island Bro. New York Pizza Stopped by on a Saturday round 5:30ish. Place was not that full, but they looked busy with takeouts. We ordered a Stromboli with Pep, Ham, and Sausage. Also, we got a Salad for two and an Italian Sub. Our friends ordered a Pizza and a Salad for two. Our orders came out in a reasonable time, and all looked good. The Salad was good it tasted fresh and had all the fixings that went with it. It was big enough for two. The Italian Sub was ok and large enough to fill you up. My Stromboli was ok not fantastic it was warm not cold but not that hot in the middle it was a little doughy and the cheese did not taste fresh. The Pizza was ok nothing fantastic there either. I must give this place 3 out of 5 stars. ⭐⭐⭐ Gulf Coast Terry

The best so far I think we’ve tried every place in Cape Coral for Pizza so far, and this is the best by far. The people were wonderful. The crust is thin and crispy. The toppings were quality, and the price was great.! We will definitely be back

Friday afternoon I expect busy, no complaint on time to get food. Someone brought in a dog, walked through the kitchen, everyone pet the dog, no one washed their hands. Had my pizza not already been in the oven, I would have left Every single piece has multiple bubbles. Very disappointed. Won't be back.

Im not a regular cheese slice person , so I don't know about their pizza , but their grandmother slice is and was delicious , everything about it was nice . And I was able to walk in at 7:15 pm and get 2 slices . They had many different slices at that time as well , so that means a lot to me because where im from there was always slices available until they close at night . So this will be a new regular spot for 2026 . 🙏