Lucifers Pizza

A very authentic place, the atmosphere is great. The pizza is delicious. The staff is friendly. The location is excellent. I recommend everyone to visit this place

This review is specifically about their gluten free pizza. Virtually every pizza shop in this part of town I’ve had GF crust from tastes like this place, like they’re using a pre-made one? I do appreciate them offering a GF option but it’s made finding legit GF pizza in this town a huge pain.

The pizza is creative from their menu. Personal or large sizes, great area to eat inside or outside. Pros: -Great place if you want a bit to eat and make your sauce spicy level. -Great environment Cons: -No parking -Must eat pizza fresh, not good when leftovers.

Maybe this is a Soup Nazi situation, and being mean to the customers is part of the appeal. If that's your thing, you'll love this place. If not, you should pick another pizzeria. We got there to pick up an order and the staff (multiple members) couldn't find the order. More importantly, they couldn't have cared less to find it and seemed angry that I was coming to pick it up. Eventually, they found the order and said it would be out. Order eventually came out about fifteen minutes later. Pizzas were cold. There was sauce literally dripping down a box, so much so that I had to ask for a napkin to clean my hands ans then the box. And they were really upset that I asked for the napkin. Try somewhere else, or order mulligatawny soup carefully, quietly, and move to your right.

It pains me to write this review. Lucifers was our go-to pizza shop, but no more. The last few times, our pizza has been dry and hard. This past weekend, we received the worst service and finally had enough. My daughter was having her first playdate, so we ordered pizza for the four girls. The pizza was cold, burnt, hard, and barely had any cheese. When I called to speak to the manager, her told me there was nothing he could do for me and that they did nothing wrong. What is this good customer service? NO! Now you have lost a loyal customer. Luckily Prince Street pizza just opened up down the block.