Made in New York Pizza

Pathetic delivery. Get a load of this thing- Delivery guy literally drops the pizza in our foyer, tucks tail and runs. Pathetic. Toppings look like he literally frisbeed the damn thing from the street. I’m sure it might have tasted good at some point; guess I’ll never know now.

Our neighborhood go-to for pizza. Friendly staff, quick service, delicious pizza. You can't go wrong grabbing a slice or two here. Limited seating inside and a few outdoor stand-up tables.

Excellent pizzas, especially the square ones that have a crunchy yet doughy and very digestible dough. The marinara is very garlicky (in a good way) and excellent as well, and the eggplant pizza is to die for. The setting is dull but it’s always useful to have a place to sit, and prices are very decent

I agree word-for-word with Jean Semere's review. I live in the suburbs but come to the UWS from time to time and always love to have a slice of the grandma-style square pizza with eggplant, which is pictured on their website. The ingredients are fresh, the sauce is delicious, and the crust is just right.

Great quality pizza ! Employees are friendly. You can request how much you want your pizza heated up