Maltby Pizza & Pasta

We were genuinely thrilled when Maltby Pizza and Pasta opened in our area, because there really aren’t many great dining options this close to home. It was exciting to finally have a local spot we could rely on for a meal without a long drive. My family does enjoy the pizza and several other items on the menu. The food is good, and having a restaurant this convenient is a huge plus for our area. The pricing does feel a bit on the higher side, especially for the pizza. So it tends to be more of an occasional treat rather than a regular stop for us, unfortunately. That said, there are definitely times when the convenience makes it worth the price, and we’re glad to have it nearby when we need it. Overall, we’re happy they chose our community, and we look forward to stopping in from time t

We had a great time here! The food was delicious, and our server was incredibly friendly and helpful. So excited we found this place.

Was in the area and came in for lunch today. I got the Italian sub and a cup of chowder. Absolutely delicious. I've only been in here one other time and had the pizza and it was also very good. But what made the journey so special was Logan. That guy is super personable, great engagement and just an all around good dude. I'll definitely be back!

Maltby Pizza is one of my absolute favorites. Best pizza near Monroe. The toppings are generous. The crust is fantastic. I just wish their sauce had juuust a bit more spice to it. Great pizza. Although, service is kind of "meh". I do have one gripe, however... Asking for a tip to bring a pizza from the kitchen to the bar is absolutely ridiculous. I ordered online, I'm standing up to either pay for or receive my food (or both). It's not my duty to pay your wait staff when I'm simply picking up a pizza. They don't even need to be involved, really. Kitchen staff could easily Just set the pizza on a shelf with my order number on it. I'll fetch it, i promise. I paid $30+ for the thing, after all.

We are in town for Christmas, the family recommended Maltby Pizza for dinner. We were sat outside in the enclosed patio area, it was cold, heater came on intermittently but was uncomfortable overall. It took over 30 minutes for our server to greet us, another 20 minutes for drinks. The food was good, service was horrible, and atmosphere was decent.