Mario's Pizzeria

Overall Score: 5.6/10 Solid pizza spot with an easy website ordering setup. Pickup was smooth and on time. Inside is a decent size, but it still feels mostly built for takeout. Cheese pizza 5.9/10 Very solid basic cheese pizza. Nothing special, but easy to finish and decent value. Cheesesteak 5.7/10 Pretty average steak and cheese, exactly what you’d expect. Grilled onions and peppers were a nice plus, with a decent amount of cheese, but it didn’t stand out beyond that. Chicken ferchetti 5.1/10 Okay overall with decent chicken, but pretty standard pizza place style. Felt a bit overpriced by about two bucks.

It’s sad to order food and u get nasty service and horrible food. I spent $45 on food that was not up to par. I asked for fresh garlic knots I received garlic knots that were def not fresh not only were they burnt there were some missing smh. I will not be returning to this pizza shop again and also the slim young girl that was working the register was nasty and gave me attitude because I wanted fresh knots. I didn’t loose my cool with her cause I have manners and I don’t have to deal with her on the regular basis. She was really upset. I didn’t only order knots and if I’m paying all this money for this food I should get what I pay for. The pizza was good a little too thin but I won’t complain cause I’m not in NY so I don’t expect it to be great. I don’t usually order food out but when I d

Ordered Zeppoles for 10 dollars, Margherita pizza and wings, online, tipped 5 dollars for for first experience pick up. When I arrived they didn’t have the zeppoles and offered to replace with a dessert. 1 cake was 6 dollars asked if I could get two. The kid at the front asked the main cook in the back and he said “porque”. They had to call the owner to add a black and white cookie for 3.50. No thoughts of courtesy, no effort accommodation. Will never be coming back. Pizza cold ( dried basil, tomato sauce and no tomato slices) , wings not tossed in sauce, did not add blue cheese or ranch as requested. Horrendous experience. Again, will never be coming back. Young girl and boy were pleasant and seemed to have the most sense. Ps they lie about checking cameras, no tomato slices, n

Thank you ... Finally some decent pizza !! Being originally from New England we know and love our NY pizza. Girl working counter was super friendly. We got the white pizza with tomato, spinach, ricotta & garlic then we got a separate pepperoni. Sizes of the pizza we're awesome, dough was thin crust was chewy with the perfect crunch ... And then the the toppings they were hefty everything was so delicious, I wish pizzas were cooked a few extra min (but just my preference) will note for next time. Can't wait to try other things on their menu!

Welcoming, casual atmosphere. The service was great and the food was like eating a home cooked meal that your Grandma would make!. We had the lasagna and stuffed shells. Both were large portions. It was so good!