Matthew's

This place has a great cozy Italian feel. I had dinner here with a friend recently and loved it. The appetizer meatballs were excellent, and for my entrée I had the fresh rigatoni, which was exceptional. Everything tasted high quality and truly authentic. I’ll definitely be back.

My First trip to Jersey and my Fiancée and her family picked Matthew’s as our 1 Italian restaurant for the trip. They have been eating there for years and couldn’t wait to take me in for a family dining experience. Let me tell you, small town restaurant, BIG TIME FLAVOR. Everything we ordered from apps to dessert was amazing. Best Italian food I’ve had in years. Our service was above and beyond, Marisa was a terrific server and really very knowledgeable, friendly, and hospitable. I had the Fettuccini Alfredo with Chicken Oregenata. The chicken was tender and juicy, the pasta was cooked perfect and the sauce with rich and creamy. Everything from the Rolls, to the Calamari, to Veal Parm(which fiancée ordered) and the Tartufo was Perfect. I will be back and will tell everyone I know that when

My brother-in-law ordered food here, for his birthday, at the last minute, post snowstorm, and Mathew came through with an amazing spread! Literally everyone said the Penne Vodka was the best they ever had and I agree! If you're in the area, you have to try it!

Went to Matthew’s Italian Restaurant last night for the first time. Exceptional food..food came out hot and was excellent. One of the best restaurants we have been to recently. The waitress was wonderful..Have nothing negative to say about the food, service or any of the help. If you like calamari…the calamari in red sauce over pasta is the best I ever had. You can get it spicy or not spicy. We give this restaurant FIVE stars

I recently visited Matthews Restaurant for dinner with my wife, and we had a wonderful experience. It was our first time dining here, and everything was truly up to the mark. We ordered Eggplant Rollatini, Cavatelli & Broccoli, and Manicotti — each dish was flavorful, delicious, and served in generous portions. The service was excellent as well, making the evening even more enjoyable. Highly recommend!