McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos

Ordered Gio's meaty specialty pizza and the Mediterranean calzone. The pizza was well baked. The meats had great flavor, the crust was great. Overall a great pizza. The calzone was huge had fresh veggies and also tasted delicious. The service was 5 star! Very friendly staff and the cook was super nice and took care of my big family.

If you’re near San Carlos by Estero, don’t let the tucked-away location fool you, McGregor Pizza Company is a real find We visited several times during our vacation with our young kids, and each visit was consistently great. The service was warm and welcoming, the wait time was absolutely reasonable (even with hungry little ones), and the pizzas were excellent across the board. Every single one we tried was delicious. It’s a small place, but that’s part of its charm. Relaxed atmosphere, friendly staff, and reliably great food. We would definitely come back. If we didn’t live 7,500 miles away lol. Only small suggestion: the restroom could use a new paper towel dispenser. If you’re in the area, it’s well worth a visit.

We are so grateful to McGregor Pizza in San Carlos Park for sponsoring our annual staff Christmas luncheon at Three Oaks Elementary! The pizza was absolutely amazing, fresh, flavorful, and a huge hit with our teachers and staff. Several staff members shared that it was their first time trying this pizza, and they were blown away! What made this experience even more special is that McGregor Pizza is a local business right here in our community. As a very community-friendly school, we truly appreciate businesses that support our school and invest in our students and staff. The generosity, quality, and kindness shown made our luncheon extra special and memorable. We highly recommend them and look forward to supporting them again. Thank you for being such an incredible community partner!

We recently visited the location on McGregor blvd and found out about the second location. Same amazing service at both locations. Highly recommend the pesto pepperoni pizza!

We recently moved to this area of Fort Myers, and discovered McGregor Pizza Co pretty much across the street from us. We ordered the first time on day two of living in our new house and have ordered almost twice a week since. We absolutely love the food, the pizzas, salads, garlic knots, calzones, all of it! So happy to have a new pizza place that is not only delicious, but the staff and owner are all so friendly, it’s just a great experience all around. Also, the prices are so reasonable, we are amazed at all the food we get every time. Definitely give them a try you will be impressed!