Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs

We ordered a medium pizza. Half supreme meat and veggies and half tomato sauce and veggies only, no cheese, vegan. We also confirmed that it was understood and asked them if we needed to explain it further. The female on the phone said, "No, we got it." We had it delivered, tipped the driver, and when we opened the box, there was cheese on everything. We immediately called and asked how cheese got loaded on the entire pizza. The same female told me it was a communication error. We asked how ordering a vegan side of pizza with only sauce and veggies was confusing. She said they would remake the pizza, but they wanted the delivered pizza back first. Just ridiculous. We will not be ordering from this Michelangelos again. The Michelangelo s in Swansboro gets it right THE FIRST TIME!!!

Our Buffalo chicken pizza was AMAZING! Only gave 4 stars because it really is pricey. $21 bucks and some change for one small pizza. It really was SO delicious though!

Yeah, so I just got a cheesesteak from there. It was dynamite not been there in a while. Next time I'm getting pepperoni blended in with it I would recommend this place live right down the road. We'll be there again.

This is one of my favorite pizza places in the area. I've been going to the one on the Island ever since the '90s. Pizza is so good

Food has always been pretty good, we go often, but yesterday I was quite disappointed to see how filthy the dining area was. Looks like it hasn’t been cleaned in a long while. They could pay a cleaning crew to do a thorough cleaning once a month in the dining area and it would look so much better. It does make a customer wonder what the kitchen/prep area looks like…..