Mikey Bagels

Mikey Bagels never disappoints! Bagels are fresh, chewy, and perfectly boiled — everything and sesame were both excellent. Cream cheese is generous and tasty. Service is lightning fast and super friendly, even at 7 AM. The place has that classic NYC bagel shop energy — love it. My go-to spot!

I walked in to this establishment, asking for a toasted plain bagel with light butter. What I received was the polar opposite of what I asked for. I thenReceived a non-toasted bagel with a lot of butter And mind you when he was putting the bagel inside of a bag. I asked the guy at the counter who I’m assuming is the owner’s son that’s a toasted plain bagel with light butter because it looked very odd to me. I then get back to my home and have come to the conclusion that I have received a non-toasted bagel with a lot of butter. Very, very, very disappointed in their service And I damn sure will not be returning back to this lying establishment . I would say thank you, but there’s nothing to thank.

Great bagels and friendly service. The bagels are always fresh and well prepared. The owner is very friendly and welcoming. Quick service and always delicious thank you 😊

I haven’t been at Mikey’s in 10 years. I think he’s an extremely nice man. Very clean place. Excellent bagels. I think the best on Staten Island. I made a special trip to go there bagels are still the best take the political satire down it just doesn’t fit in the store. Everybody has a different opinion politics and bagels don’t go together.😳

Just went here for the first time and it was delicious! Great bagels, fast and nice service, with a nice atmosphere inside. I got a half a dozen and they gave an extra to me for free. Definitely come here if you're in the Staten Island area!