Mitch's Seafood

This was so good we came here twice. This small restaurant has some amazing food options that will leave you very, very satisfied. Price is a bit high, especially for the grilled options, but they are absolutely worth it. Staff is also very friendly, helpful and nice. It is very busy, we were lucky to find a place. I can't even imagine how busy it is in summer. My favorite was the Fisherman's Stew, an absolute must if you come here. Also safe for celiacs and people with gluten allergy, only a few options are not gluten free in the menu and they are very much aware of them. Fisherman's Stew: 10/10. Please order it if you come here, it will blow your mind. Whole lobster: 10/10. Amazing flavor, sides also very, very good. Grilled wahoo: 8/10. It is amazing, but honestly a bit pricey given th

Great spot. It’s definitely not well advertised and if you’re not specifically looking for this place, you likely won’t notice it. On the main side of the building, all you see is a bait shop. You have to be all the way to the left (east) side to even see a sign and entrance. Despite that, it’s fairly crowded and there’s a line to order. The food is well priced, prepared with love, and definitely fresh. This is the place for seafood lovers. I had lobster, clam chowder, salad, and mussels. The chowder wasn’t that creamy but lots of clams. Mussels were also not super plump. But the lobster was very fresh and well done. I’d be back to try the grilled fish next time.

This place is an absolute gem! We had the chowder soup and it was super good and full of amazing taste. We also tried the Spiny Lobster which was cooked perfectly, super fresh and flavorful. Their lemonade stood out! My husband had the wahoo fish and he loved it. The view while eating is also incredible. Highly recommended if you are a seafood lover.

We heard about Mitch's on someone's blog and are so glad we went after whale watching. The view is perfect, the beer selection varied and good, the line moves quickly and there weren't just "fish tacos" but you got to choose your fish variety and they explained the different ones, even though it was busy. All was so fresh and yummy! We recommend the poke which was "melt in your mouth tuna". The grilled rockfish tacos were also really good with loads of fish in each. Get several things to try and enjoy the harbor view for a while!

Enjoyable location, friendly staff, good food. The fish tacos have a little bit of diced jalapeño on them so be aware of that if you don't want some slight heat. The chowder was a bit peppery but I enjoyed that.