MTK Lobster House

This restaurant is located kind of in an odd spot (upstairs of a donut store) and on the west side of town. We visited on a Saturday night around 5:30p and there was no one in the restaurant. As we were sitting inside in the AC, a few more parties came. All the work staff was very nice and attentive the entire duration of our visit. Right away brought us a pitcher of tap water and glasses. When we finished that pitcher, not even a minute later, a new and cold fresh pitcher arrived. We ordered the crispy calamari to start, which is served with a Thai sauce and a marinara sauce. The calamari was so tasty and the Thai sauce.. yum! We could’ve licked that Thai sauce clean. We ordered the cold lobster roll (which on the menu is named something different) and it comes with chips. The chips we

I really looked forward to trying the lobster roll here but was left disappointed by the meal considering the prices. The signature lobster roll was a bit bland - the most memorable flavor being too buttery. I wish the butteriness could’ve complimented the lobster better instead of being the main flavor. The calamari was pretty average, but the sauces it came with were a good touch.

The food was absolutely delicious! I visited with a party of four, and everyone thoroughly enjoyed their meals. The lobster roll, clam chowder, and crab bisque were all exceptional. Our waitress was wonderful, even though she was very busy, she provided attentive and friendly service. We truly enjoyed having lunch here and I would definitely return. Highly recommend!

Had an amazing dining experience at MTK Lobster House in Montauk! I opted for the Surf & Turf Burger while my wife enjoyed the Montauk Lobster Roll, and both dishes were exceptional. The flavors were spot on, and you could really taste the quality of the ingredients. The ambiance and service were equally impressive. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a top-notch meal in Montauk! 🌊🦞🍔

Nice place. Came with our own file fish and got refused by manager. Even though we are loyal customers for many many years. So left the file aside and ordered meal from the menu. Love Montauk beer. This place has wine and beer only. Tacos were delicious. Mussels were in butter and garlic sauce. In average it is a good place to come. Very great service by waitress. Thank you for that. The only one thing I had to tell the girl who was bringing the plates was to cover nose with a mask. Cause the mask covered only her mouth.