Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY

Excellent Pizza, Wings ,Subs, Salads & Sides! No Matter what you order, it's perfect & delicious everytime! If you haven't tried Muscarella's Pizzeria, I suggest Please Do! Prices, Quality & Food Menu is Perfect! Thank you Muscarella's Excellent Food for sure 5 Stars!

Love love LOVE this pizza, but when I went to ask a question about a wing flavor, I was ignored and the older woman just cut me off and kept speaking to a coworker without acknowledging me!!! It was soooo rude! A male coworker witnessed it and apologized on her behalf, but that was just awful! Just for asking a question about wing flavors. It was awful!

Wings (Cajun) burnt, honey sesame crust burnt black, and pizza had that thing going on where you lift the cheese to wipe away way too much sauce. Did not feel the same as the Main St one in Williamsville. I too did a Door Dash and feel like it left a lot to be desired…

I’ve been eating at Muscarellas for a while and I have never had pizza so good.The whole place looks clean and well took care of.The Italian wings are to die for.I definitely recommend to anyone.

The Pizza was too doughy.The sauce was too sweet. Good quantity average quality