Mustafio's Pizza

This place is amazing, especially for halal pizza. We ordered the pepperoni and chicken pesto pizzas and honestly couldn’t decide which one we liked more. Both were so good, and I know this will be our go-to pizza spot from now on. The server was really sweet, and the prices were great for the quality and portion size. The place itself isn’t fancy and isn’t very well maintained since it’s a small spot, but the pizza completely makes up for it. Plus, they stay open late, which made it the perfect end to our concert night. Loved it!

My father owned a pizza place, and pizza was his religion. I am a pizza snob, and I am giving 5 stars. The owner treated me like his daughter, with a smile at 3:30 am as he is closing. Cut my slices for easy eating in the car made me feel so loved. Pizza (pepperoni and pesto chicken) is crispy, quality, delectable goodness! Pesto tastes pretty fresh actually! Restaurant is SPOTLESS. My only regret was not getting the cheesecake! I am so glad I walked out of the hole in the wall up the street. This was a night and day better experience. Will be back!

I walked here, pretty far out of my way, because of all the excellent reviews. If you like soft, greasy, soggy pizza - which apparently some people do, more power to them - this is the place for you. Otherwise, friendly service and average to below average pizza. Not a 4.7 star pizza.

I don't understand these 5 star reviews. The pizza I had was very underwhelming. Maybe because it was late at night, but given the raving reviews, I was expecting more. Soggy crust, undercooked toppings, and very bland flavor. I literally threw the entire 14" pizza away. Are we eating the same food? And $12 for a really basic side salad with highschool cafeteria Caesar dressing? This is not a 4.7 star rating restaurant.

Sheik is a boss among bosses serving up the Polk and post corner for quite some time. Prices are cheap and pizza is amazing! He’s a really awesome guy and always very friendly. I would recommend to anyone! 🏳️‍⚧️Trans Friendly🏳️‍⚧️