Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon

This want to be "Chicago deep dish pizza" is AWFUL. The crust is very tough and the bottom was burnt. It doesn't contain much cheese or ingredients. This pizza had huge chunks of onions and green pepper and little meat. It made us wonder, if the cooks even knew how to cut up veggies. This pizza doesn't taste anything like the delicious pizza everyone loves in Chicago. Chicago deep dish pizza has tons of cheese with tons of delicious toppings, plus the crust isn't hard and never burnt. Nancy's pizza needs a lot of work. Their price is extremely expensive and the pizza doesn't contain the ingredients, your expecting or paying for. The customer is not getting their money's worth. If you truly love Chicago style deep dish pizza, don't waste your money on this knock off. We also tried their loa

I stopped in while passing through to try their Chicago-style pizza. It was fantastic! Great flavor, crust, and cheesy goodness. I’ll definitely stop by again next time I’m in town!

We were so excited to get their pizza. Then we had issues with their website. Once our order was entered the coupon that’s good through 11/30/25 said we had to have the app. We downloaded the app and the coupon for 30% off wouldn’t work. We called and the girl said the manager said they expired and there’s nothing they could do! WTH! By this time I was like, my time is valuable so this is the last $109 and change they will get from us!! Monical’s will be getting ALL our business from now on. Bait and rip us off NO MORE!! Edit- Shanney reached out to explain there had been a miscommunication and would be taking this to corporate. The coupons should have worked. She did make the situation right and we look forward to giving them another try.

Good pizza, stuffed isn't my favorite, though. Definitely in the same league as Giordano's. I ordered the Uncle Tony's (Italian sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions.) Since this location is carry-out only, it had cooled off by the time I got home. The mozzarella cheese still had a pull to it when I put a couple of pieces on my plate, and the mixture of flavors collided in mouth for a good tasting pizza.

Ordered Nancy's for delivery. We got 3 pizzas. My son liked his thin crust pepperoni and pineapple. The Uncle Tony's deep dish was great. The thin crust spicy pepino was good and actually had a good amount of spice. The price was a little crazy for 3 pizzas @ over $100. This would definitely be a place we would order from again if we want good pizza.