New York Luncheonette

A bit disappointed after all the hype. We had pancakes and the tuna melt. Pancakes were fine but nothing special. Tuna melt was cold in the middle, actual tuna salad was dry. Fries were kinda cold as well. Service was wonderful. Really wanted to line this place more. They were given awards for helping during 9/11 and President Obama went there etc. but it was just okay. I'll try it again and order something different just to see if i can have a better opinion.

This place is a treasure. Fast, friendly, efficient, and exactly what you expect from a breakfast spot. I brought my family here on a whim because it was across from our hotel. It was bustling but the line moved fast. The staff is like a well oiled machine, getting you your food quickly and moving people in and out as a team without rushing the process. I came back when I was in town on business by myself and sat the bar. Was amazed to see how they handled traffic up close, how quickly they turned around my requests, and how much the crew was clearly enjoying each other. They’re not reinventing the wheel here, but honestly this fast, friendly, no BS breakfast is exactly what you would expect from a midtown diner. Shout out to the grill guys who were absolutely crushing it. Recommended!

Came here for lunch with a friend yesterday. We were greeted quickly and our waiter was very friendly and attentive, which was the highlight of the visit. Unfortunately, the restaurant had an unpleasant smell when we walked in. The fries were great, but the sandwich I ordered was very bland and lacked flavor, especially for the price. The fountain drinks also upset our stomachs later. Both my friend and I ended up feeling sick afterward and I even threw up later, so something didn’t sit right with us. I ended up having stomach cramps the rest of the day as well — possibly from the deli meat. It’s unfortunate because the service was really great, but the food quality and overall experience were disappointing.

Came in for breakfast. Ordered oatmeal with blueberries and a side of ham. The oatmeal was luke warm. At least the blueberries were plump and fresh. The ham was slimey, wet, cold slices of boiled lunch meat ham. No attempt even to sear them well on the griddle. Yuck. I couldn't eat them.

New York Luncheonette has that classic New York diner vibe that’s getting harder to find. It’s been around for decades, and you can feel that local history when you walk in. We stopped in for brunch and the food was straightforward and satisfying. The bacon came out perfectly crispy just like we asked, the portions were generous, and everything was exactly what you’d expect from a traditional diner breakfast. Nothing overly fancy, but just solid brunch food done well. The crowd felt like a mix of tourists and locals, which makes sense for a place that’s been part of the neighborhood for over 30 years. It’s also a great spot if you want a quick sit-down meal without committing to a long brunch experience. When there’s no line, you can easily get in and out in under an hour. If you’re loo