New York Pizza

Yummy and affordable pizza. You really get family style vibes from the workers. All of them were super friendly and made the wait worth while. I’ve lived here a year and this was my first time visiting. You can’t beat $4/slice of pizza in this town. The salad is even less that $5! I’ll be back again :-).

This is not NY pizza so don’t get your hopes up. Crust was not cooked enough and too sweet. Not enough sauce, too much cheese. Gabriella’s near Lake Merritt is much more authentic to NY style. Bathroom was dirty for a restaurant. Staff were very tired and not friendly but they were polite. No atmosphere. Need music on to filter the loud sound of the soda machine. This place needs help. Potential is there. I won’t go back.

Sorry to say, but this was disappointing. Ordered through Doordash and after waiting more than an hour, the driver arrived and informed me that they forgot to cook a dish that we ordered and had to wait around for it. Okay, no biggie, as long as I got it, so be it.... Then when I opened the bag, the order was wrong. Alright, at this point, annoyance is setting in... Then, I bit into the (incorrect) pasta I received, only to discover its not even fully cooked. That annoyance just leveled up to Pissed. Seriously?! Must be amateur hour over at New York Pizza tonight. Additionally, to call this pizza "New York Style" is a bit of a stretch... Breadsticks were okay... But i have to give this one a Hard No. Sorry to say, but I've tasted better food at Olive Garden.

This is our favorite pizza place in the East Bay! Love their thing crust, pizza sauce and generous toppings!

Best pizza in alameda crispy crunchy crust like a New York slice should be and wonderfully nice people running the shop.