New York Pizza

I was introduced to this place early 2025. Since then my fiancé and I have fallen in love with this restaurant. This is our first place to go to celebrate birthdays and anniversaries. I compete in combat sports: grappling and MMA, so my diet is strict through the majority of the year, to celebrate after a competition win or loss, this is my go to spot to EAT, I love their Favorite and Caprese pizzas, both go great with chicken, the greek salad is also wonderful. The owners here are so kind and respectful, they remembered my birthday after not seeing me for about 5 months, they make this place very special. 10/10 would recommend for a fun, cozy little spot to enjoy good food with friends.

Mixed experience. This occurred on February 3, even though I’m just now speaking about it. I walked into the bar area and waited to be acknowledged while three people were sitting there, and no one said anything to me. A white couple walked in after me, and one of the men at the bar immediately greeted them, asked if they were picking up or dining in, and directed them where to go. The difference in treatment was noticeable and uncomfortable. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, which was good, and the cook in the back was the only person who was kind to me. However, I also ordered empanadas through DoorDash that were advertised as coming with 4, and I only received 2. Because of the service and the incorrect order, I won’t be returning.

I don’t know how I hadn’t tried this place before, dive bar attached to a great pizza place. Highly recommend the “favorite”, I added anchovies

Really good made to order pizza! After you order, you can watch them make your pizza through the window. My friends had the veggie pizza, wings, and buffalo chicken pizza. I just had a sweet tea and a cannoli. The cannoli was super sweet (a little too sweet for me), which may have been because of the chocolate drizzle on top. I tried both pizzas and I was pleasantly surprised with the veggie pizza! It was really tasty. The buffalo pizza was just ok. Every employee we interacted with was super friendly and the owners made sure we had everything we needed when we got our food. They have a nice variety so if I’m ever in the area, I’d go to try some other things. Super nice people and good pizza close to UNCG!

Ordered food from this establishment once but never again. Found long blonde hair strung through the inside of the pizza. What was more unfortunate was that I had found it after I had already bitten down. Went back to the restaurant with picture proof asking for a refund. The owner tried to blame the hair on us (both of us have black hair) even though there was very visibly a lady with long blonde hair working near the pizzas with hair sticking out her hair cap. Instead of a refund, he offered a free pizza the next time we came back. Why would I want another pizza from an establishment who served me a hair pizza? I would maybe have given it another chance had the owner even ENTERTAINED the idea that his employee with uncovered hair got hair in the pizza, but no. First and last time buying