New York Pizza Pub

Let me start by saying this used to be the top pizza place in New Braunfels. There is nothing, in my opinion, better than an authentic NY pie and this place used to deliver that. Huge foldable slice with enough greasy cheese that it could take a napkin to sop some of the grease off! Ah those were the days. Fast forward to the latest visit and while the place has been eclipsed for a while by several better quality pizza places which while maybe not “New York”, took their pizza to a level this place wasn’t hitting. Now however I’m almost ashamed to say, this place is a shadow of its former self. The slice isn’t foldable anymore because it’s more like a cracker it’s been in the oven so long. The sauce is uninspired and lacks flavor. The cheese is very very light, frankly, tastes like maybe th

great food and big portions! we got the mega mozz sticks and xl buffalo + bbq tenders. a bit pricey, but worth checking out.

My husband and I have scoured just about every pizza place in the city, and this one is definitely among the best. The cheesy bread has that perfect crispy crust and amazing flavor — it’s addictive! Their calzones are equally impressive — packed with flavor and, best of all, they don’t get soggy. You can tell they use quality ingredients and care about what they’re serving. We’ll absolutely be back — easily one of our new go-to spots for pizza night.

The pizza tasted like a "premium" frozen pizza. The toppings were very small and had pre-minced ham and such like frozen pizzas do. I was expecting better considering a large is $26. Got there at 11:30 am on a Wednesday before the lunch rush. We were the only ones there besides 3 people at the bar who looked like they'd been there a while. We ordered one pizza and it took over 30 minutes. I told the waiter I needed a small pizza to-go when we placed our order (so it'd be ready when we were ready to leave). We finished eating and I asked about the small pizza and the waiter said he hadn't even put it in yet. Which totally defeats the purpose of me telling him about it when we placed the initial order. So we had to wait another 35-40 min for that small pizza as the lunch rush was now there.

My husband and I loved this place, we would go pretty frequently. After the phone call I just had with what I’m assuming was the manager, I’m good. My husband ordered food for dinner one day this week and when he went to pick it up the staff told them they were closing early because they were slow and canceled our order. One of the staff wrote down a note that we could get a free pizza for the inconvenience. The purpose of my call was to get said pizza. The girl I spoke to first was very nice and willing to look into it. I was placed on hold and then the manager picks up and asks how he can help. I told him the situation and he goes “well I can’t do much with a piece of paper with no manager signature” and he asked what day the order was placed. I couldn’t remember (not something a simple