New York Pizzeria

Had an issue when my father tried to order pizza under this "new management." The food was great after my father inquired about the Sicilian being made, to find out they are made from the start of the morning and reheated with extra fresh stuff on top to make it look good. It wasn't bad. Had a family outing yesterday evening, with children and adults, and there was NO care in this pizza or baked spaghetti. The baked spaghetti was more watery than the spaghetti, which was the only thing I can say (besides the side of bread for it) that was even worth the 100 I spent there. Baked spaghetti should not consist of more water than anything else. The Scicilian also tasted like dough, not fully cooked in the middle, and this is how we got the pizza (see photo attached). No, we did not call for the

Absolutely love this place! The Philley Cheesesteak is incredible—comfort food done right. Their New York–style pizza is spot on with a perfect crust, and the spaghetti brings a smile and full belly to my sons everytime. On top of the great food, the atmosphere is warm and family-friendly, which makes it even better. This has become our go-to spot and we’re always happy when we come in. Highly recommend

Absolutely love this place! The lasagna is incredible—comfort food done right. Their New York–style pizza is spot on with a perfect crust, and the wings are always flavorful and cooked just right. On top of the great food, the atmosphere is warm and family-friendly, which makes it even better. This has become our go-to spot and we’re always happy when we come in. Highly recommend!

We met the owner Justin, he was amazing and so was his staff. The pizza he made for us was the best we’ve had in years, way better than Tony’s pizza in the mall, and we live in Kingston and came all the way to Jacksonville for this New York pizza, and boy it makes your mouth water just thinking about it but once you get there there’s not much left after you leave. We will definitely be back again!!!

I ordered a pizza from DoorDash, but it only had pepperoni on half of it. So, I called them and mentioned I was a bit frustrated and hungry after a long day at work. I hung up the phone. When I went back to check my order, I realized there was a problem with how you place an order on DoorDash. The short version is that I called and apologized to the manager for being rude. He offered to replace my pizza, even though it wasn’t their fault. I declined because, as a business owner, I appreciate when an issue is recognized and a solution is offered. I didn’t need a free pizza, but what I really needed was the patience of the team, who acted professionally and politely. Thanks, everyone! Also, the adult side of my pizza was amazing, and the sub was great too!