New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria

Fantastic Reuben! Nice crunch, tender meat, great pop of flavors. I’ll let the pictures speak for themselves. The Rockefeller pasta salad was great, but a little more oil would take it over the top. On my list of stops next time I’m in town. BUT BEWARE - they prefer cash. There’s a credit card fee that’s a bit sketchy. Just raise your prices by 3%. I hate that stuff… and I’ve always heard it’s not legal or ethical.

Outstanding deli with a great range of hot and cold sandwiches, pizza, and desserts (pies, cookies, brownies, cakes...). I went for the New Yorker muffuletta which was super tasty...and the 1/2 sandwich portion was just right to leave some room for key lime pie. 😉

I have lived around Pensacola all my life and today was my first time at New Yorker Deli. I will say I have missed out! The menu is filled with so many delicious choices. I love a good Muffalatta and they did not disappoint. Had a side of the Rockefeller pasta salad and it was great. So many pasta salads to choose from. We’ll be back!

I thoroughly enjoyed my lunch at this little taste of Italian cuisine. The atmosphere was awesome, as well as the service. I sat inside and went to enjoy the outside shaded area. I met the manager and told him how much I enjoyed the fantastic tasting food. A definite must try if your in east Pensacola on Cervantes St.

We have been coming here for over a decade. They treat us as if we are family. All of them are amazing people and employees. Shout out to Don for also being a great photographer. The food is always on point. You can tell they take the extra step to make every meal exactly what you came for and then some. Keep up the good work guys. We will continue to spread the word.