Nick & Toni's

I’ve been to Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton many times over the years, and it’s always a pleasant experience overall. The staff was kind enough to make our anniversary dinner feel special, which we really appreciated. The ambiance is lovely — warm, lively, and quintessential Hamptons — and the service is consistently attentive without being overbearing. That said, the food continues to leave me with mixed feelings. The appetizers were just okay this time around, nothing particularly memorable. The tilefish entrée was excellent — perfectly cooked and full of flavor — but the beef stew was a real miss. It was chewy, lacking depth, and tasted like it hadn’t been cooked long enough. Honestly, I make a better version at home. All in all, Nick & Toni’s remains a nice spot for a special occasion o

We had a wonderful time last night. Our waiter Moses guided our entire experience and made recommendations that we loved. We had the zucchini fritti which was lovely, but we felt it needed a sauce. My boyfriend had the chicken which was delicious and I had the short rib ravioli which was tasty! For dessert we finished with olive oil cake which was light and refreshing. Would recommend!

Visited for the $32 Two-Course Pizza & Pasta Prix Fixe. Excellent food. Excellent service (I suspect thanks to being off season). The wait staff coming to tell me the pasta special was SEVEN agnolotti not the SIX he had sold me, was a little over the top, but attention to detail is important

This review is a little late, but my husband and I had dinner here last month while we were in town. The service was phenomenal. For an appetizer we got the Zucchini Fritti which I highly recommend. It's a large portion, so easily shareable. They are also addictive, and we had them polished off in no time flat. My husband also enjoyed the fig salad. For entrees, I had the roast chicken, and my husband had their market catch (I believe black bass?) For dessert, we ordered the Tartufo. You could probably feed 4 with that thing, lol. It was great, although I wish the chocolate was more prominent. The only issue I had with our visit was the seating. We were sat in the doorway of the room we were in, which was fine, except that my husband couldn't sit across from me or he'd be in the way. So

A quite lively environment! My experience was ruined by the location of my table. My chair/back was up against the hostess stand, and I was either having to get up to let the staff pass or keep getting bumped against the table as they squeezed pass. The lamb was excellent…the cocktails were great…the desserts—not so much