Nick's Pizza & Pub (Carryout & Dining Separate hours)

Great pizza! Salad and sandwiches were good as well. Large portions and very good prices. Come enjoy this classic bar that had been around for years. You will know why once inside and eating.

​"Nick’s Pizza & Pub in Crystal Lake is a high-velocity community engine and absolute Godnews for the local grid. It is a gold-standard witness to hospitality, where the fluent, professional service and high-impact lodge atmosphere are handled with undeniable authority. As the architect of Neighbor-Proof Marketing, I recognize this location as a premier node for building neighbor-to-neighbor legacy. From the 10/10 thin-crust pizza and elite hospitality to the perfectly synced environment for families, every visit is a masterclass in consistency. If you want the best seat for an authentic experience that defines the 2026 pace of trust, this is the only one that matters. A verified, iron-clad 10/10."

Bruchetta was really good. This is the first pizza where someone put slices of bacon vs diced. Very disappointed and very underwhelming. We asked for well done and this was not. Really wanted to like this place. The atmosphere is fun and our server was great. Not sure if this is their creative take or pure laziness from the kitchen staff. Sadly, we won't be back.

We tried the Bruschetta along with the Delicious!, and each dish was full of fresh, satisfying flavor. A simple yet delicious start to our meal.

I’ve been going to Nick’s Pizza in Crystal Lake for over 30 years, and I can say without hesitation that it is, by far, the best pizza around. The quality has been consistently outstanding for decades. The crust has the perfect balance of crispy and chewy; the sauce is flavorful without overpowering the toppings, and the ingredients are always fresh. Whether dining in or carrying out, the food has remained dependable and genuinely exceptional. What truly sets this place apart, however, is the staff. The team is absolutely incredible. They are welcoming, attentive, and clearly take pride in what they do. There is a strong sense of consistency and professionalism that keeps longtime customers like me coming back year after year. General Manager Monica deserves specific recognition. She is