Nonno's Cellar

We had the Walleye, which was cooked very well. The side salad was good with just enough toppings. The reason for the 4 w as that the desserts left something to be desired. Italian restaurants, in my opinion, should have a top-notch tiramisu. What I had tasted like frozen. I can honestly say I make a better one than that. Our server was amazing 👏.

The stars are for the atmosphere, love the brick and tile on the floor. The people were nice, however, our waitress definitely needed more training. (Reaching her arm across us, instead of walking around, very slow to refill our glasses etc.). The presentation of the food is awful, we waited way too long to get get it and once it was finally brought to our table, 3 out of 4 of our meals were cold! Even the baked potato was cold!!! I got the Italian beef and noodles and it was not good at all, the food overall was average at best. We were excited to try your restaurant but left really disappointed to say the least. To their credit, they credited each of us $20….so we still paid over $35 for a subpar meal. Unfortunately I cannot recommend this restaurant.

My wife and I went to Nonno's Cellar for our valentines dinner. And it was delicious! It did take a little bit for the food to come out. BUT everything tasted fresh and was hot. The atmosphere in there was amazing for a 1 on 1 intimate date. Could probably do with a few less tables to make it feel more private but it is a business after all. Otherwise absolutely loved our time there and it will definitely be back again!

I had Linguine with red shrimp sauce. It was excellent. My wife had 4 cheese ravioli that was very good. The house garden salad with the meal was also fresh and very good. Topped off the meal with cheesecake. Definitely plan on returning.

A rare, unique, premium, dining experience in Lima, Ohio. This is the perfect spot for “date night” with incredible food and an even more incredible atmosphere. There’s nothing else even close to it in Lima. Even more impressive is the competent, professional service. It’s a great way to spend a nice evening and highly recommended.