Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

Visiting everytime during NY vacation. This is hands down the best bagel in the world. Stretchy texture, smell, size... I love to eat plain bagel here without toppings, because it's great how it's.

Bagels were really good. Dense, with good chew and flavour. Freshly baked and with a good variety. But for me what really set this neighbourhood spot apart was the amazing homemade cream cheeses. Whether a traditional cream cheese flavour or flavours I have never seen anywhere else before, they made for delicious bagel sandwiches. Friendly counter staff

Amazing bagels but my order is always wrong. They don’t take allergies or diets seriously. If you order tofu cream cheese, you’ll either get regular cream cheese or meat/fish. I’ve gotten so sick after eating here several times. Can’t go back despite the bagels being the best.

Very no frills bagel shop but honestly so good!! Had the whole grain bagel w cream cheese and it was perfect and not too heavy!

Really solid bagels. Super fast service. No indoor seating or bathroom. You’ll carry your bagel out with you. There are benches outside which you can sit on. Ordering, here’s a little bit interesting, you’ll start a loop that goes between the refrigerators and shelves, and it’ll take me to the far end of the counter where you’ll order. once you’re done ordering, they’ll give you a piece of paper with your items, kind of like a receipt. You’re done go along the counter to the cashier where you’ll pay. Once you’re done paying you wait after the cashier until your items ready to pull out your number and I’ll give you your stuff.