Papa Johns Pizza

Our company buys food for employees there when we do a good job i ate there maybe 4 times threw company never had a issue but on Thursday 2/19/2026 Whatever company serves Nassau Provisions food distributor in holstville weather Selden or Patchogue i had 3 slices third slice I bit into a small rock/pebble or piece of glass and broke 1 of my two front teeth 🤔 in conference room around 2 Supervisors and 15 other staff members so much pain so embarresed tooth cracked pass gumline future advice drop a pie on floor by accident do the right thing throw away the done pie or doe that falls anything that's on the floor the human eye might not be able to see will imprint and cook in the crust then the person that eats the pizza will suffer like I am for 6 days now

This Papa John's in Patchogue is conveniently located on route 112. Nice staff and great food you can carry out or have them deliver. In the winter or when the weather is bad. Papa John's will come lol 🍕 🥤.

I ordered pizza from this location off of Uber eats I paid close to 20 dollars I ordered Buffalo chicken pie regular crust they sent me grilled chicken with pepperoni and onions on a thin crust pie when I called the location a lady named mini answered and told me she made the pie and she sent me my correct order and then when I asked her name repeatedly she didn’t tell me and hung up the phone then I called back and asked again and that’s when she told me and then said her manager comes in tomorrow or the following day such bad service and to think someone like that is making my food disgusting

I don't know what it is about Papa John's but they are not using real mozzarella in my opinion. It just doesn't taste or look the same as a regular New York slice

I used to love this pizza franchise. Today, I am afraid of Botulism! After ordering from this particular franchise three different times in a six month period, I would not recommend eating here. Each time I ordered delivery, there was always something wrong with the food. The last two times i ordered, I had to call management to let them know that there was a problem, but, those problems fell on deaf ears and never got corrected. Chicken wing dipping sauce has a valid expiration, however it must be stored in a hot location because it gets delivered Rancid. Buffalo wings delivered are only half prepared with only a drizzle of buffalo sauce and are not fully cooked (pink meat near bone). Leads me to believe that pizza toppings are nor fresh at all. Im sorry, the food was soo bad that i had t